Is $1,950 to repair a front porch railing a fair price?

This quote is for replacing rotted spindles, railings, and repairing a damaged post. The homeowner is responsible for disposing of the old wood. - Replace rotted spindles on stairs - Replace railing on stairs - Replace porch railing with new spindles - Repair damage to one of the posts

This quote is for replacing deck railing and railing posts. - Deck Railing Length: Approximately 80-90 linear feet - Deck Height: 8 feet off the ground - Stairs: 2 flights - Post Replacement: 13 railing posts (some difficult to replace) - Board Replacement: A few boards need replacement - Board Removal: Some boards need to be removed to access and replace posts - Reinforcement: Blocking needs to be done to reinforce - Railing Material: Timbertech railings - Labor Includes: Demo and dump

This quote covers the demolition of an existing massive brick porch and the construction of a new 5x6 wooden porch with stairs. The project includes: - Demolition and disposal of the existing brick porch and concrete - Construction of a new 5x6 wooden deck with stairs - Labor for the entire project - Other costs for replacing a damaged side The existing metal handrails are being reused. The homeowner initially noted concerns regarding inconsistent gaps between treads and risers, miscalculated step placement, and stringers directly anchored into concrete, which the project manager has agreed to address.