Is $21,132 to replace 36 square roof with class 3 architectural shingles a fair price?
Project Details
The roof is 25 years old and was damaged in a storm. Insurance valued the replacement at over $27,000 but only offered $5,100 after depreciation and a 1% deductible. The homeowner is located in a high wind/hail area in central Wisconsin.
Quote Details
Full roof replacement including materials, labor, and disposal. - 36 SQ Class 3 Architectural Shingles (IKO Dynasty or Owens Corning Duration) - Hip and Ridge Shingles, Starter, Ice and Water Shield, and Synthetic Underlayment - Ridgevent, Drip Edge/Gutter Apron, Valley Metal, and Pipe Jacks - Detach and dispose of 3 satellite dishes - Re-flash skylight and step flashing - Tear off and replace shingles (31.47 SQ at 4/12 pitch and 1.04 SQ at 8/12+ pitch) - Dumpster for disposal
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$21,132
Quote Date
April 8, 2026
Location
Wisconsin
Roof size
36 squares
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace dwelling roof with architectural shingles
Full replacement of 18.35 squares of roofing material including: - Tear off, haul, and dispose of existing laminated composition shingles - Installation of ice and water barrier (489.38 SF) - Installation of 15 lb. roofing felt and peel-and-stick asphalt starter - Installation of laminated composition shingles with 30-year rating - Installation of standard profile hip/ridge caps and shingle-over style continuous ridge vent - Replacement of drip edge and gutter aprons - Flashing for pipe jacks and detach/reset of digital satellite system - Additional charges for high roof sections (2 stories or greater)
Replace 35 squares of roofing with mid-range architectural shingles
Full roof replacement for a 35 square area. - Remove existing 24-year-old roofing material - Install mid-range architectural shingles (Class 3) - Replace damaged plywood decking at porch dip areas - Standard installation for Upstate NY climate (snow and ice considerations)
Replace roof with 36 squares of owens corning duration architectural shingles
Complete roof replacement including tear off and removal of existing materials. - 36 squares of Owens Corning Duration Architectural Shingles - Synthetic Roofing Underlayment - Ice and Water Shield - Starter Course Shingles - Metal Drip Edge - Hip and Ridge Cap Shingles - Owens Corning VentSure Ridge Vent - Pipe Boot Flashing - Goose Neck / Stem Vents