




Is $100,000 to replace cedar deck boards with composite and address structural issues a fair price?
Project Details
I am a decent DIYer and usually handle my own projects, but I've been busy and decided to hire a company to replace my cedar deck boards with composite. My deck is 1,000 sq ft. I received two bids around $100,000, which I find to be quite high, so I'm now considering doing the work myself again. The joists and the rest of the understructure are in good condition, except for a missing beam at the start of the lower deck level where there's a step down. This seems sketchy, and I've noticed a dip in the center of the deck near the house. The two companies I got quotes from suggested different solutions for this structural issue, and I'm unsure which is better. It would be difficult to dig new 4 ft deep footings under the deck here in CT, and I'm not sure if I can find a company willing to do just the footings. I'm also thinking about switching from composite to Ipe or a similar hardwood because composite gets very hot, and I don't want to deal with annual staining required for PT or cedar. I'm open to oiling Ipe. For railings, I'm considering horizontal cable railings. I'd appreciate ideas for covering the underneath of the deck beyond white lattice, and I'm also looking into installing an under-deck protection system for dry storage. I'm confused about whether to use joist tape due to conflicting opinions. Lastly, I'm wondering if there's a benefit to replacing existing posts with 6x6s or creating 4x6s by joining 2x4s.
Quote Details
This quote involves the comprehensive replacement of existing cedar deck boards with composite material for a deck approximately 1,000 sq ft in size. The project also includes addressing a significant structural issue concerning a missing beam at the transition point where the deck steps down to a second level. Two distinct approaches were proposed for this structural repair: - Solution 1: Install a new beam along with a row of concrete footings and supporting posts. - Solution 2: Eliminate the stepdown/multi-level design by raising and extending the existing joists, and installing taller posts at the end of the deck.
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Decking
Price
$100,000
Quote Date
August 23, 2025
Location
Connecticut
Material
Composite
Square footage
1,000
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Repair a 10x24 deck with composite boards
The project involves repairing a 10x24 deck, addressing both cosmetic and minor structural issues. The scope of work includes: - Replace a 10' 6x6 post- Replace 4-5 joists- Re-deck the entire 10x24 deck with composite boards

Replace an 800 sqft deck with a simpler 300 sqft composite deck
This quote is for replacing an existing 800 sqft deck with a new, simpler composite deck, reducing the size by excluding the 500 sqft hot tub portion. This company is available next week and does not charge for overhead and profit.
Replace deck floor with pressure treated wood
Quote for replacing the deck floor and making structural improvements using standard pressure treated wood. - Complete deck floor replacement (16x22) - Up to 3 joist replacements - Add 2 additional posts (for code compliance) - Material: Standard pressure treated wood