Is $53,200 for extensive masonry repair to rowhouse stoop stairs and landings a fair price?

Question

The project involves extensive masonry repair to the rowhouse stoop stairs and landings, including correcting out-of-code treads and risers, and addressing the lower door replacement.
- Demolition:
- Install wood frame under all landings to hold debris and ensure safe tenant entrance.
- Demolish all 11 concrete steps and 2 landings.
- Remove and save all existing railings.
- Scrape all loose paint on columns and nearby areas prior to demolition.
- Remove the existing door.
- Construction:
- Install 2-inch metal deck on the main landing with #4 rebar at 12-inch on center in every direction for reinforcement.
- Wood frame and concrete pour all 11 steps with #4 rebar for reinforcement.
- Install bluestone over new step treads and around the main landing.
- Install a new metal door.
- Rebuild any brick around the new door and lintel.
- Apply base coat, mesh, and color finish stucco over all brick columns and all around the door entrance and up the stairs.
- Purchase, paint, and install new railings. I rarely hire contractors and usually do everything myself, especially interiors. This project is beyond my capabilities, and I lack pricing context. I've received other much lower quotes, but I believe they didn't fully account for the difficulties. I also have a contractor I've used before who is good at job analysis, but I don't trust his crew's execution. I'm evaluating if this $53k price is reasonable for a NYC area job. I'm also considering the cost of bluestone versus sandstone, though it seems to be a small fraction of the total price.

Is $53,200 to extensive masonry repair to rowhouse stoop stairs and landings a fair price?

Project Details

Quote Details

You say...

More Details

Source

Comments