Is $4,300 to repair a ceramic tile roof valley a fair price?
Project Details
I am in a difficult situation regarding my nearly 100-year-old ceramic tile roof. I was getting water in a closet and hired a roofing company for a valley repair. They started the work, which involved replacing the metal valley and removing tiles, but it took longer than expected (4 days instead of 2). They went all the way to the top of the roof and claimed they ran out of usable tiles, stating my existing tiles are in poor condition and keep breaking, making it hard to find matching replacements. They have now stopped the repair and are pushing for a full roof replacement, offering a discount. I haven't paid them for the initial repair yet. I'm concerned this might be a tactic because they went over budget or want my old tiles. I would prefer not to pay for a new roof right now and am leaning towards keeping my current tiles. I want to know if I can ask to help find replacement tiles or if color-matching is an option. The original metal valley was rusted out. I want to approach them respectfully, but I also want them to finish the job if I decline the new roof.
Quote Details
This quote was for a valley repair on a ceramic tile roof. The initial scope of work included: - Replace the metal valley - Remove tiles up to 10 feet The company began the work, extending beyond the initial scope by going all the way to the top of the roof. They reported running out of usable tiles from my roof and had difficulty finding matching replacements. The work took 4 days instead of the estimated 2 days. The company ultimately stated they could not complete the repair due to the poor condition of the tiles, which kept breaking.
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$4,300
Quote Date
February 1, 2026
Location
Ohio
Roof material
Tile
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Repair a ceramic Spanish tile roof
This quote is for repair work on a ceramic Spanish tile roof. The work includes: - Remove cracked/damaged tiles at service areas (approximately 30 tiles) - Inspect and repair underlayment to match existing - Install new tiles at service areas, glued at channels using Chemlinks roofing adhesive - Prep and clean existing flashings and vents - Seal vents using Chemlinks roofing adhesive - Coat vents using a color-matched, rust-prohibiting paint Please note: The company cannot guarantee an exact color match for new tiles due to aging and product availability.
Repair a tile roof
This quote is for repairing a tile roof on a 1500 sq ft single-story house. - Remove and replace 5 broken roof tiles, furnishing and installing new tiles to match existing as closely as possible. - Clean off the entire roof of all debris, including behind the chimney, in the roof valleys, and cleaning the gutters. - Clean the roof-to-wall areas (confined rakes) to ensure pan flashing is clean and water sheds down the roof without issue. - Reseal all roof vents and plumbing vents with new silicone roof sealant and rubber collars over the plumbing vents. - Remove and dispose of all work-related debris upon completion of repairs.
Replace 2 valleys and repair leaky roof
This quote is for replacing two roof valleys and repairing a leak. The scope of work includes: - Taking up tiles approximately 4 feet on each side of the valleys - Repairing any underlying issues