Is $15,000 to replace a flat roof with 180 torch rubber a fair price?
Project Details
We've got some ponding and damage from recent snow storms and a blizzard to our flat roof and are looking to get things fixed. We have no experience with this whatsoever and are seeking advice on whether these options are reasonable in terms of scope and price. The roof is approximately 670 square feet.
Quote Details
This option involves a full tear-off and replacement of the existing flat roof. - Removal: Rip up existing layer down to the plywood - Insulation: Install new insulation layer - Underlayment: Peel and stick underlayment - Top Layer: 180 torch rubber
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$15,000
Quote Date
April 8, 2026
Location
New York
Home Size
670 sq ft
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Remove and replace 2,400 sqft of flat roof with a granulated modified roll rubber torch-down system
The quote is for the removal and replacement of 2400 square feet of flat roof. The original estimate was $28,000, but a special offer reduces the cost to $22,800 if accepted within a few days. The project includes: - Roof Removal: Existing roofing materials will be removed down to the decking. Removed materials will be properly disposed of. New wood decking will be installed in one designated area where the carport roof meets the house roof. - Insulation Installation: Roof insulation will be installed using screws and 3-inch plates, ensuring even distribution across the entire roof area. - Synthetic Base Sheet Installation: A synthetic base sheet will be applied to the entire roof surface, ensuring proper adhesion. - Granulated Modified Roll Rubber Torch-Down Roof System: A new granulated modified Roll Rubber Torch-Down roof system will be installed to cover the entire roof area, using proper torch-down techniques for a watertight membrane. - Roof Penetrations: All roof penetrations will be wrapped with modified rubber torch-on roof system for added durability, with best practices implemented to seal around penetrations to prevent water ingress. - Chimney Flashing: A new modified roll, rubber torch roof system will be installed to the chimney, and a termination bar will be installed for a watertight seal. - Flashing and Coping: All coping stones will be sealed using Rubber roof cement. Any broken coping will be replaced. - Soffit Removal and Replacement: Damaged soffit will be removed from a designated area and replaced with new soffit board to ensure structural integrity. - Warranty: All work is covered by a 15-year warranty.
Replace flat roof
This quote is for the replacement of a flat roof section, approximately 240 square feet. - Rip out old decking - Replace decking - Install new membrane
Install new torch-down rubber roofing system
Installing new torch down rubber roofing system to existing main roof. - Installing new edge metal - Installing new drain box - Applying cement and fabric to all edges and seams - Includes 12-year guarantee contingent on periodic maintenance