Is $8,000 to replace asphalt shingles a fair price?
Project Details
My initial impression is that the quote to install the 1/4 plywood sheathing is high, especially since it's nearing the cost of new shingles. The sheathing is proposed to meet warranty requirements due to potential board gaps exceeding 1/4 inch, which could void the entire roof warranty. I am questioning whether it's more financially sensible to forgo the sheathing and save the $5500 to cover potential storm damage repairs myself, especially since we experience hurricanes. I've confirmed with the shingle manufacturer that my existing 1" thick board roof deck meets minimum thickness requirements, but I'm still clarifying their specific requirements for maximum board-to-board gaps and overlaid plywood thickness for warranty purposes. I am also considering an upgrade from the base 30-year shingles to a higher grade.
Quote Details
This option covers the installation of new asphalt shingles, utilizing the existing roof deck without additional sheathing. The quote is based on the following specifications: - Shingle Type: Base 30-year asphalt shingles - Roof Type: Hip roof - Roof Dimensions: 31' x 38' - Roof Pitch: 3 - Roof Area: 14 square (includes 10% overage) - Sheathing: Existing roof deck will be used; no additional plywood sheathing is included in this cost.
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$8,000
Quote Date
October 1, 2025
Roof size
14 squares
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Warranty period
30 years
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace asphalt shingles on my roof
This estimate is for the replacement of the existing asphalt shingle roof, including the following items: - Tear off: Existing shingles (1 layer) - Decking: Inspection, replacement of up to 2 sheets of plywood (additional cost for more) - Underlayment: Synthetic underlayment (e.g., GAF FeltBuster) - Ice and Water Shield: In valleys and eaves (e.g., GAF StormGuard) - Edging: New drip edge - Flashing: Around penetrations (vents, chimney) - Shingles: New asphalt shingles (e.g., GAF Timberline HDZ) - Ridge Cap: New ridge cap shingles - Ventilation: New attic ventilation (e.g., GAF Cobra Ridge Vent) - Cleanup: Debris removal and disposal
Replace delaminated roof sheathing with new plywood
This quote is for a change order to replace delaminated roof sheathing discovered during a roof replacement project. - Removal: Old 3/8" sheathing- Installation: New 1/2" plywood
Replace asphalt shingles and plywood on roof
This quote is for a complete roof replacement, including removal of old shingles and installation of new materials, along with guarantees for material and labor. - Removal of all old shingles - Installation of new GAF Timberline UHDZ shingles (whole house) - Weather watch installation - Synthetic underlayment installation - Ice and water shield: 6 ft installed from all eaves and valleys, around pipes, low pitch planes, and around the chimney (Timbertex) - Ridge cap installation - Drip edge installation around the entire house - Ridge vent: Cobra exhaust vent - Material Guarantee: 25 years - Labor Guarantee: 10 years - Shingle Cost: $8,925 - Plywood Cost: $5,040 - New Velux Skylight Cost: $850