Is $37,000 to replace 3,600 sqft of roofing with GAF shingles a fair price?
Project Details
I received quotes from three roofing companies and am seeking suggestions. It's challenging to blindly trust what companies say, as they often try to promote their specific products. I'm unsure about the quality of GAF versus Certainteed and am trying to determine the appropriate duration for a workmanship warranty, specifically if 25 years is necessary.
Quote Details
This quote is for replacing 3,600 sqft of roofing. It includes: - Roofing Material: GAF - Workmanship Warranty: 25 years (Master Elite)
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$37,000
Quote Date
June 29, 2025
Location
California
Home Size
3,600 sq ft
Roof size
3,600 sqft
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Warranty period
25 years
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace a 6,000 sqft roof with GAF certified installation
This quote is for replacing a roof with a little over 6,000 sqft of actual area. The roof has a steeper pitch in parts and is mostly south facing. The company is a GAF certified installer, which they state is one of only 2% of certified installers in the US for this product. This certification provides a 50-year warranty on the product. - Roof Area: A little over 6,000 sqft - Roof Pitch: Steeper in parts - Roof Orientation: Mostly south facing - Shingles/Materials: Same as other quotes (GAF implied) - Installer Certification: GAF certified (one of 2% in US) - Product Warranty: 50 years (due to GAF certification)
Replace roof with GAF shingles and new gutters
This quote is from a bigger company with a receptionist, sales person, and their own machinery. - Shingle Type: 50 GAF shingle - Workmanship Warranty: 10 years - Manufacturer Warranty: 50 years - Inclusions: Complete redecking of the entire roof, new gutters - Note: The sales person did not go on the roof or in the attic during the estimate.
Replace asphalt shingles with GAF materials
This quote includes the removal of existing shingles and the installation of new GAF roofing materials. The work covers a roof that is approximately 1150 sq ft, has a 45-degree pitch, and includes one dormer. - Shingle Removal: Existing shingles will be removed. - Underlayment: GAF Stormguard and Feltbuster will be installed. - Edging: Drip edge will be installed. - Starter Shingles: GAF starter shingles will be installed. - Main Shingles: GAF Timberline HDZ shingles will be installed. - Decking: Roof deck will be replaced where needed. - Ventilation: GAF Cobra ridgevent will be installed. - Accessories: New pipe boots and vents will be installed.