Is $14,333 to replace roof with GAF Timberline HDZ shingles a fair price?
Project Details
I am looking for a full replacement of my 21-year-old roof. I received quotes from three reputable installers in suburban Michigan. The scope of work was the same across all companies, but they use different shingles. All three shingles are Class 3 rated for hail, which is sufficient for typical thunderstorms, but I do have harsh winters. I plan to stay in this home for up to 15 more years. My main question is whether Malarkey or Certainteed shingles are significantly better than GAF Timberline HDZ to justify the $2K price difference. All quotes include labor, but since they are from different installers, I'm unsure about the labor and material breakdown per quote.
Quote Details
This quote is for a full roof replacement using GAF Timberline HDZ shingles. The scope of work is consistent with other quotes received. It includes labor and the shingles are Class 3 rated for hail. - Shingle Type: GAF Timberline HDZ - Hail Rating: Class 3 - Inclusions: Full roof replacement, Labor
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$14,333
Quote Date
August 21, 2025
Location
Michigan
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace roof with GAF Timberline HDZ shingles
Full roof replacement using GAF Timberline HDZ shingles.
Replace roof with GAF Timberline HDZ shingles
Replace the 30-year-old roof. - Shingle Material: GAF Timberline HDZ - Warranty: GAF System Plus Warranty
Replace roof with GAF Timberline HDZ shingles
This quote is for a complete roof replacement, including the removal of existing shingles and installation of new GAF Timberline HDZ shingles. The project includes comprehensive protection for the property and disposal of all debris. - Property Protection: Cover the house all around with tarp to protect the ground, siding, and windows. - Shingle Removal: Take off existing shingles down to the deck. - Plywood Installation: Supply and install 5/8 Fire rated plywood all over the roof surface. - Ice/Water Shield: Supply and install GAF Storm Guard ice/water shield all around rakes/eves, valleys, pipes, chimney, skylights, etc. (6ft ice-water shield underlayment along eaves). - Synthetic Underlayment: Supply and Install GAF Roof Breathable Deck Armor Synthetic paper all over the roof. - Starter Shingles: Supply and Install GAF Pro-Starter shingles on all eves and rakes. - Pipe Boots: Supply and Install Pipe Boots Flashing. - Drip Edges: Supply and Install aluminum 10 - Step Flashing: Supply and install step flashing along walls and chimney. - Chimney Cricket: Supply and install new cricket behind the chimney as required by Building Code. - Chimney Flashing: Supply and install copper flashing around chimney. - Power Vent: Supply and install new GAF Power Vent. - Attic Ventilation: Supply and install new vents as needed for attic ventilation. - Shingles: Supply and Install GAF Lifetime Timberline HDZ Shingles (color chosen by owner). - Ridge Vent: Supply and Install GAF Cobra Ridge Vent SnowCountry. - Ridge Caps: Supply and Install GAF TimberTex Ridge Caps. - Wall Flashing: Supply and install aluminum flashing along walls all around the house. - Debris Removal: Remove and dispose of all debris related to this project (dumpster will be placed on driveway). - Nail Removal: Magnetic roller will be used to remove all nails around the house. - Shingle Fastening: 6 nails per shingle. - Manufacturer Warranty: Lifetime (50 Years). - Workmanship Warranty: 30 Years.