Is $312,500 to replace GAF TruSlate with DaVinci Inspire artificial slate a fair price?
Project Details
We have a large roof and are considering replacing our failing GAF TruSlate (real slate, but with a proprietary underlayment and mounting mechanism) for either DaVinci Inspire, or a high quality asphalt shingle like GAF Camelot. I'm looking for thoughts about the longevity, support, and overall appearance of these options.
Quote Details
This option involves replacing the existing failing GAF TruSlate roof with DaVinci Inspire artificial slate. - Existing Roof Material: GAF TruSlate (real slate with proprietary underlayment and mounting mechanism) - New Roof Material: DaVinci Inspire artificial slate - Roof Size: 180 squares
You say...
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$312,500
Quote Date
November 15, 2025
Home Size
18,000 sq ft
Roof size
180 squares
Roof material
Slate
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace asphalt roof with DaVinci multi-width slate composite (Bid 1)
This quote is for the tear-off and replacement of an asphalt roof with DaVinci multi-width slate composite shingles. The project involves 50 squares and 12/12 slopes with 11 flashings. The vendor was found via social media/rating sites and had solid ratings. - Shingle Material: DaVinci multi-width slate composite - Components: DaVinci where available, GAF for items DaVinci doesn't make - Flashing Material: Steel (copper available as an upgrade) - Certification: Certified by DaVinci (not master level) - Waste Estimate: 20% (software estimated) - Gutter Recommendation: Strongly suggested newer, larger gutters due to DaVinci's edge compared to asphalt - Sub-contractors: Unsure if used
Replace asphalt shingles with GAF materials
This quote includes the removal of existing shingles and the installation of new GAF roofing materials. The work covers a roof that is approximately 1150 sq ft, has a 45-degree pitch, and includes one dormer. - Shingle Removal: Existing shingles will be removed. - Underlayment: GAF Stormguard and Feltbuster will be installed. - Edging: Drip edge will be installed. - Starter Shingles: GAF starter shingles will be installed. - Main Shingles: GAF Timberline HDZ shingles will be installed. - Decking: Roof deck will be replaced where needed. - Ventilation: GAF Cobra ridgevent will be installed. - Accessories: New pipe boots and vents will be installed.
Replace shingles with GAF Timbertex
Quote option for replacing roof shingles. - Shingle Material: GAF Timbertex - Roof Characteristics: Has a lot of parts and is pretty steep