Is $2,700 to replace 20 deck boards (additional charge) a fair price?
Project Details
I am having a new roof put on and got several quotes, choosing one in the middle range. Now, after they've already started, they are asking for an additional $2700 to replace 20 deck boards. I'm questioning if this is right, as I feel the quote should have been accurate from the start. The contractor had looked in the attic, taken pictures, and seen mold. I also informed him about two leaks and showed him ceiling stains. Despite discussing the likelihood of needing to replace some deck boards, the original quote stated 0 extra deck boards. I feel he knowingly left this out to secure the contract. They also found a third layer of roofing during tear-off. I was initially told I wouldn't be charged for it since he missed it, but it was included on the change order.
Quote Details
This quote is for an additional charge to replace 20 deck boards, issued as a change order after roofing work had already commenced. The contractor had previously inspected the attic, observed mold, and was aware of two existing leaks. The original quote had specified 0 extra deck boards, despite prior discussions about potential replacements. A third layer of roofing was also discovered during the tear-off process, which was included on the change order, though I was initially told I wouldn't be charged for it.
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$2,700
Quote Date
October 19, 2025
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Install a new roof with redecking
This quote is for a new roof installation. The initial quote of $10,000 included redecking due to the presence of old boards. The price was later increased to $16,000 because the roofer found more rot in the old boards than initially expected. - Scope: New roof installation - Redecking: Included due to existing old boards - Price adjustment: Increased from $10,000 to $16,000 - Reason for price increase: More rot in old boards found than expected
Replace roof and full redeck after storm damage
This quote is for a roofing job that initially involved replacing one half of the roof due to storm damage (covered by insurance) and replacing the other half (homeowner's portion). The final invoice included additional work for a full redeck on both sides of the roof. The contract specifies billing rates for additional work if discovered during the job. - Initial Scope: Replace one half of the roof due to storm damage and replace the other half. - Additional Work: Full redeck on both sides of the roof. - Billing Rate (Additional Shingle Layers Removal): $45 per 100 square feet. - Billing Rate (Deck Replacement): $60 per 4x8 sheet, including disposal of old material.
Replace roof and some rotten boards
This quote is for a roofing job that included the following work: - Replace roof - Replace 3-4 boards with small rotten spots