Is $17,000 to replace entire roof a fair price?
Project Details
I initially contacted the contractor for chimney flashing repair. After inspecting the roof, the contractor claimed I needed a whole new roof based on two photos showing minor issues (exposed nails, chimney flashing). The roof is only 10 years old, and another contractor disagreed that a full replacement was necessary. The quoted price was around $17,000 with a high-pressure deadline. I am skeptical of the contractor's assessment and urgency, especially considering their incentivized reviews and the fact that they initially told my wife there were 100+ holes but only provided photos of minor issues when asked for proof. I believe the issues shown in the photos are repairable. I am located in the Northeast.
Quote Details
Based on an inspection citing exposed nails and chimney flashing issues, the contractor recommended a full roof replacement. - Contractor claimed there were 100+ holes and risk of water damage. - Contractor urged a quick decision due to "tariffs".
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$17,000
Quote Date
May 16, 2025
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Repair a roof leak and rusted nails
This quote is for repairing the existing roof based on a contractor's inspection. - Identified Issues: Rusted nails, leak near the chimney area - Scope of Work: Repair to address the identified issues
Replace roof
Scope of work included the installation of a new roof. - Install new roof - Replace step flashing - Includes 10 years labor warranty
Complete tear off and reroof
This quote is for a complete tear off and reroof of the 1700 sq ft roof, addressing multiple issues found with the current installation. Problems identified: - Multiple soft spots in sub roof. - New roofing consists of two kinds of material, not properly sealed. - There are currently 4 layers of roofing, which is against code and a structural risk. One layer is heavy gravel and tar. - Wrong type of drip edge installed (should be thicker galvanized metal, not bent aluminum). - Sides of roof finished incorrectly with no gravel stop metal. - Faux chimney needs replacement. Job includes: - Complete tear off of existing roofing layers. - Hauling away debris. - All necessary material and delivery. - Installation. - Seven year warranty on labor. - Twelve year warranty on material from the manufacturer. - Inclusion of up to three pieces of plywood (additional pieces are $125 each installed). - Note: Removing the gravel roof layer adds $3315 to the price, which is included in the total.