Is $17,000 to replace entire roof a fair price?
Project Details
I initially contacted the contractor for chimney flashing repair. After inspecting the roof, the contractor claimed I needed a whole new roof based on two photos showing minor issues (exposed nails, chimney flashing). The roof is only 10 years old, and another contractor disagreed that a full replacement was necessary. The quoted price was around $17,000 with a high-pressure deadline. I am skeptical of the contractor's assessment and urgency, especially considering their incentivized reviews and the fact that they initially told my wife there were 100+ holes but only provided photos of minor issues when asked for proof. I believe the issues shown in the photos are repairable. I am located in the Northeast.
Quote Details
Based on an inspection citing exposed nails and chimney flashing issues, the contractor recommended a full roof replacement. - Contractor claimed there were 100+ holes and risk of water damage. - Contractor urged a quick decision due to "tariffs".
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$17,000
Quote Date
May 16, 2025
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace entire roof
The quote was for an entire roof replacement. The homeowner has significant concerns about the quality and execution of the work, specifically noting the following issues: - Roof sheets and cap pieces are made of metal sheets layered overtop of one another, which the homeowner describes as looking "trashy." - Siding was cut at the bottom and slid up under the flashing, left looking unfinished, raising concerns about it ripping off due to high winds. - The new roof design causes water runoff to completely miss the gutters and go straight to the ground. - Two vents on one side of the house were eliminated during the replacement.
Replace entire roof
This quote is for an entire roof replacement due to multiple issues identified during a home inspection and homeowner observation. The existing roof shows signs of structural and installation defects that may compromise its functionality and warranty. - Noticeable wave in the roof - Sections of the roof are "springy", indicating possible structural damage to the plywood decking - Previous repairs by the seller did not include a starter row for shingles - Gutters are not graded well, potentially voiding the CertainTeed roof warranty - Insulation in the attic is installed upside down, which may contribute to humidity problems and plywood deterioration - Inadequate ventilation: presence of ridge and gable vents but no soffit vents - The replacement would involve addressing structural damage, replacing plywood decking, underlayment, and shingles
Replace a full roof
This quote is for a full roof replacement. The scope of work included: - Full roof replacement - Replacement of all necessary wood decking