Is $5,800 to replace the rear half of the roof including solar panel removal and reinstallation a fair price?
Project Details
Purchased a home in Contra Costa county with a transferable 2-year leak warranty from a previous repair. After a major storm, the same area leaked causing hardwood and drywall damage. The original roofer claims the previous repair wasn't enough and is now quoting for a larger scope while threatening litigation over the warranty dispute.
Quote Details
Full replacement of the rear section of the composite shingle roof to address recurring leaks under solar panels. - Removal of existing solar panels - Installation of new composite shingle roofing on the rear half of the house - Reinstallation of solar panels - 5-year guarantee on new work - Price includes a discount due to failed previous repair attempts
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$5,800
Quote Date
May 23, 2026
Location
California
Home Size
1,300 sq ft
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Warranty period
5-year guarantee
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Repair a roof leak under solar panels and reinstall them
This quote covers the repair of a roof leak located under a leased solar panel array. The work was performed after the leasing company's 5-year leak warranty had expired, but with their approval. During the removal of the panels, the roofer discovered multiple cracked tiles and areas with water damage. - Remove existing solar panels - Replace underlayment on the affected side of the house due to significant water damage - Install a Pegasus solar tile mounting system - Reinstall the solar panels - Add a bird guard
Replace architectural shingles and flat roof with solar detach and reset
Full roof replacement for 27.61 squares including a steep roof section and a flat roof section. - Remove existing shingles down to the deck - Inspect decking and re-nail loose wood; rotten wood replaced at $90 per sheet - Install drip edge at eaves and rakes - Install 3 feet of Owens Corning WeatherLock ice and water shield at valleys - Install synthetic underlayment - Install Owens Corning Starter Strip Shingles - Install Owens Corning Oakridge Limited Lifetime Dimensional Shingles - Install 6 new lead pipe flashings and 1 new rain cap - Install 72 linear feet of new ridge venting - Seal all penetrations and flashings - Modified Bitumen roofing for flat roof area (approx. 4.47 squares) - Solar detach and reset of 23 panels - San Antonio permit fee included - 5 year workmanship warranty on roof and 10 year warranty on solar craftsmanship
Fully replace the roof
This quote is for a full roof replacement. - Scope of work: Full roof replacement - Primary issue: Small leak in living room, located approximately 3 feet inside the edge of solar panels - Additional concerns: Overall condition of existing shingles, presence of a 'hump' on the roof ridge