Is $1,700 to replace 13 shingles and aluminum fascia lining a fair price?
Project Details
The homeowner previously used this company for a similar repair (10 shingles for $400) a few years ago and was expecting a price adjusted for inflation, rather than a 3x increase. They feel the current quote represents price gouging relative to the estimated labor and material costs.
Quote Details
Repair of damaged roofing and fascia components. - Replace 13 damaged shingles - Replace approximately 20-25 feet of 6-inch aluminum fascia lining
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$1,700
Quote Date
April 9, 2026
Location
Indiana
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace a 13 sq roof
This quote is for replacing a 13 square (1300 sqft) roof, which currently has double-layered shingles. The price includes a 5% cash discount. The work involves: - Permits: Included - Debris Removal: Hauling away all old roofing materials, including double-layered shingles - Plywood Replacement: Replacing approximately 6 squares (600 sqft) of rotted plywood - Fascia and Gutters: Replacement around the area where the leak originated - Ice and Water Shield: Application 6 ft along all eaves, 3 ft in valleys, and 18-24 inches around all penetrations, skylights, walls, or chimneys - Deck Tape: Applied over all plywood seams - Starter Shingles: Installed along all roof edges - Shingle Fastening: Shingles to be secured with ring-shank nails - Shingle Type: IKO Dynasty shingles - Roof Warranty: 50-year warranty on the roof - Shingle Granule Warranty: 15-year warranty on the copper/anti-moss granules in the shingle
Replace roof, gutters, siding, and fence staining
- Remove and replace approximately 57 squares of laminated composition shingle roofing - Additional charges for steep roof (7/12 to 12/12 slope) and high roof (2 stories or greater) - Installation of 15 lb roofing felt, drip edge, valley metal, and step flashing - Installation of ice and water barrier (363 SF) and asphalt starter course - Installation of high profile hip/ridge caps and 72 SF of standing seam metal roofing - Replacement of 466 LF of 5-inch aluminum gutters and gutter apron - Replacement of 160 LF of aluminum downspouts across four elevations - Repair of 350 SF of fiber cement lap siding including painting - Pressure cleaning and staining of 1,855 SF of wood fencing - General conditions including project management, permits, driveway protection, and debris removal
Replace a residential roof
This quote is for the replacement of a residential roof, covering 15 squares (1500 sqft). - Shingle Removal: One layer of existing shingles - Underlayment: Ice & water shield, synthetic underlayment - Edging: Drip edge - Shingles: GAF Duration - Flashing: Chimney flashing, including a 1/2 inch cut using an angle grinder for proper installation - Crew Size: 5 workers - Completion Time: 7 hours