Is $25,000 to replace the whole shower a fair price?
Project Details
I bought a home without thoroughly looking at the shower. I noticed dark brown/black stains on the caulking during inspection, which the inspector thought was mildew. We got it tested, and the results said 'could be mold'. I've tried cleaning the caulking many times with various products, but it never fully came clean. After using hypochlorous acid and an electric scrubber, I found that the caulking is cracked or missing in many places. I'm worried this indicates a mold problem coming from the subfloor. I'm a first-time homeowner and have no experience with this, having lived mostly in military barracks before. I have anxiety and a tendency to spiral, and I'm concerned my husband will think I'm overreacting if I suggest replacing the whole shower based only on my opinion.
Quote Details
The quote, initially for a new shower floor, was revised to a full shower replacement due to structural concerns. - Initial request: Replace shower floor only - Reason for full replacement: Removing the shower floor would compromise the sealant behind the walls - Scope of work: Full shower replacement
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Bathroom Remodeling
Price
$25,000
Quote Date
February 2, 2026
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace a walk-in shower due to failed grout
This quote is for the replacement of a walk-in shower due to failed grout and water seepage. - Problem: Grout in the shower has failed, causing water seepage that is leaking to the unit below and into the baseboard and walls. - Scope of Work: Total demolition and reinstallation of the walk-in shower. - Exclusions: The drain pan was inspected and found to be fine.
Inspect for mold in a shower
This quote is for an inspection by a mold remediation company to assess the mold issue in the second-floor shower. The inspection will determine if mold has spread under the tiles or behind the wall.
Gut and replace a shower
The existing shower will be gutted and replaced. The new installation includes: - Acrylic shower pan - 3 acrylic walls - Glass enclosure - Hardware