chippyo

Is $4,900 to replace a 75-gallon gas water heater a fair price?

Project Details

I have a gas water heater that's turning 15 this year, so it's definitely time to start thinking about replacement. It's not showing signs of full-on failure but the burner is getting markedly less efficient (the flame is mostly yellow). Since our utility room is on the third floor, it's best to be proactive about these things; a substantial leak up there would be very bad. I was quoted $4900, which is much higher than I was bracing myself for based on Internet research. I'm unsure how much the complicating factors (75-gallon unit, third-floor location) should drive up a reasonable estimate. $5000 is about double what I was expecting to hear, and I'm wondering if I should keep looking.

Quote Details

This quote is for the replacement of an existing gas water heater. - Water Heater Capacity: 75-gallon - Water Heater Type: Atmospheric gas unit - Venting: Flue pipe comes out of the top and travels approximately three feet to join the furnace flue. - Installation Location: Third-floor utility room - Labor: Includes removal of the old unit and installation of the new unit on the third floor, involving two flights of stairs.

Thank you for your feedback!

You say...

?
How would you rate this quote?
TooCheap
GoodDeal
FairPrice
BitPricey
Ripoff

Vote Distribution

Too Cheap0 votes
Good Deal0 votes
Fair Price0 votes
Bit Pricey1 votes
Ripoff0 votes

These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.

More Details

Category

Plumbing

Price

$4,900

Quote Date

February 22, 2026

Comments

No comments yet

Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.

Similar Quotes

replace a 75 gallon natural gas power vented water heater
Pennsylvania
Plumbing
$4,600
Jun 3, 2025

Replace a 75 gallon natural gas power vented water heater

This quote includes the supply and installation of a new 75-gallon natural gas power vented water heater, along with all necessary piping and fittings. - Water Heater Type: 75 gallon natural gas power vented - Included Components: Mixing valve, Expansion tank - Piping Material: 3/4 copper - Fittings: All 3/4 fittings needed to assemble the water heater correctly

Awaiting feedback
Plumbing
$3,800
Jul 23, 2025

Replace a 75-gallon water heater tank

This quote is for the complete replacement of a water heater, including the unit, installation, and removal of the old unit. - Tank Size: 75-gallon- Services Included: Installation, Removal of old tank, Purchase of new tank

1 rating
Plumbing
$5,500
Aug 11, 2025

Replace a 40 gallon gas hot water heater

This quote is for the replacement of a hot water heater. - Type: Gas hot water heater - Capacity: 40 gallons - Location: Second floor

1 rating