Is $35,000 to renovate the entire pool (tile, coping, plaster) a fair price?
Project Details
I've owned the pool/house for about a year, and this is my first pool. Last year, I noticed a narrow horizontal crack around parts of the spa, above the waterline, which might explain a suspected leak from a previous inspection. This year, after extended travel, I discovered the issue, assuming it's from water getting behind the tile and freezing over winter, despite the pool being professionally closed. I've cleaned up some sand and broken tiles, but more sand is spilling out. The pool is from 2000, and the plaster and coping are tired, but I hoped to get a few more years out of them. I'm concerned about risking further damage, especially to the bond beam, if I don't address this soon. I'm wondering if a localized repair is possible or if I need to commit to a full renovation, which I estimate to be around $35k. I also personally redid all the mastic last season, so I'm sad to think it might be ripped out. I'm also curious if it's common for the mortar bed to break down over 25 years and if not addressing it now will lead to higher costs later.
Quote Details
This quote is for a full pool renovation, addressing existing damage and updating tired components. The pool, built in 2000, has tired plaster and coping, and is experiencing significant issues. - Existing Damage: Narrow horizontal crack around parts of the spa (above the waterline), suspected water ingress behind tiles, sand spilling out from behind tiles, and broken tiles. - Suspected Cause: Water getting behind the tile and freezing over winter. - Scope of Work: Full replacement of pool tile, coping, and plaster.
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Pools
Price
$35,000
Quote Date
July 30, 2025
Year Built
2000
Pool Type
In-ground Concrete
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes

Replaster a pool
Quote includes the following work: - Pressure test - Plumbing check - Tile and plaster removal - New tile and plaster - Deck o seal

Replace pool tiles
This option involves replacing the pool tiles that have fallen off. It is being considered as a potential temporary solution to get a few more years out of the pool before a more extensive repair.
Replaster an inground pool in bad condition
Quote for replastering an inground pool that is in very bad condition. - Completely chip out existing plaster - Waterproof the pool shell - Replace the pool plaster - Test the existing pool pump