Is $4,500 to replace a rubber flat roof a fair price?
Project Details
I had my rubber flat roof replaced two years ago for between $4,000 and $5,000. I specifically instructed them to replace whatever was necessary to ensure it was done right and would last. However, I've noticed obvious spots where water pools after every rain, and areas of flashing bow out when it's hot. I'm concerned about these issues, as I was under the impression a new flat roof with repaired substrate shouldn't collect water. I've learned that good craftsmanship isn't always commensurate with price and that finding reliable vendors can be difficult. I'm a DIY professional and often find myself needing to correct basic issues with expensive work I've purchased. I plan to stay in this house long-term and am investing in repairs and upgrades. I'm also considering painting the seams with silicone pre-emptively.
Quote Details
This quote was for the replacement of a flat roof, specifically a rubber flat roof. The scope of work included replacing whatever was necessary and repairing the substrate to ensure the roof was done correctly and would last.
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$4,500
Quote Date
October 2, 2025
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Repair a flat roof
- Scope: Repairing the flat roof to address leaks caused by installation errors. - Contractor's View: This option is presented as a temporary solution or "bandaid" by the contractor, who recommends a full replacement instead.
Repair/replace a roof
This quote was for a roof repair/replacement, including the following work items: - Scaffolding- Skip- Removal of roof tiles, old zinc valley, and flashing- Application of new breathable membrane- Application of new treated timber batten- Reinstatement of all lead flashing around the roof with new code 4 lead- Application of current tiles back to roof and replacement of any broken/defective tiles- Application of ridge tiles back on using dry ridge system
Replace a flat roof
This quote is for the replacement of a flat roof, including the cost of additional plywood sheets and a warranty. - Roof Area: 900 sqft - Additional Materials: 8 sheets of plywood - Warranty: 10 years