
Is $26,300 to replace roof with Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration Architectural Shingles and replace skylights a fair price?
Project Details
I am requesting a comparison of two roofing quotes for my house in New England. Both quotes estimated the roof at 34 squares, and my eaves have returns, which will require more work. I am leaning towards Option 2 but want to understand how the shingle choices compare, as Owens Corning seems to be commonly used in my area.
Quote Details
This option is for replacing the roof using Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration Architectural Shingles. This company uses subcontractors for the work. The quote also includes the replacement of skylights. The roof size is estimated at 34 squares, and the eaves have returns, which will require additional work.
You say...
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$26,300
Quote Date
June 21, 2025
Roof size
34 squares
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace a 34 square roof and 3 small skylights
This quote is for the replacement of a 34-square roof and three small skylights. - Roof Size: 34 squares - Skylights: Replace 3 small Velux skylights - Venting: Install full linear vent, lifetime vent sleeves - Other Components: New drip - Shingle Material: Owens Corning Duration

Replace roof with Owens Corning Duration shingles
This quote is for a full roof replacement. - Shingle Material: Owens Corning Duration shingles - Drip Edge Material: Matte black
Replace asphalt shingles on a 26-square roof, including skylights
Roof replacement on a 26-square roof, including tear-off, decking inspection and replacement, aluminum wall flashings, ice and water shield, synthetic underlayment, shingles, vents, and cleanup. - Total roof squares: 26 - Tear Off: Remove and dispose of 2 layers of existing asphalt shingles and roofing system down to roof decking. - Additional layers tear-off: $30 per square (10'x10') for removal and disposal if found. - Roof Decking: Inspect and replace damaged boards/sheets as necessary. - Plywood Replacement: First 5 sheets of 1/2" CDX plywood replaced at no additional cost. Each additional sheet $60 for 1/2" plywood. - Aluminum Wall Flashings: Inspect and replace, if needed, for $20/ft. Includes cutting siding 4" up from roof line, removing old flashing, installing ice & water shield on roof decking and up the wall, installing new aluminum step flashings, and installing new PVC trim boards. Painting to be done by homeowner. Reused wall flashings remain covered under TopTier Roofing's installation warranty. - RhinoRoof Granulated Ice & Water Shield: Install 6' along all eaves, 3' wide roll down any valleys, around all penetrations, and against any wall lines to protect vulnerable areas from ice and water damage. - RhinoRoof U20 Synthetic Underlayment: Install directly on the roof decking wherever the ice and water barrier is not installed, providing a secondary layer of protection. - Owens Corning Starter Strip Shingles: Install along all eaves to create a watertight seal and prevent shingle uplift and blow-offs. - Owens Corning TruDefinition Duration Architectural Shingles: Install in accordance with the manufacturer's recommended installation guidelines with electro galvanized roofing nails. - Lomanco Lo-Omni Ridge Vents: Install to provide proper ventilation of the attic space. - Owens Corning ProEdge Hip & Ridge Cap Shingles: Install to cover the ridge vents, ridges, and any hips. - Rust-Proof All Metal Roof Vents: Spray paint all metal roof vents with high-temp paint to rust-proof and enhance durability. - Clean Up and Disposal: Provide on-site dumpster and dispose of all job-related debris. Use magnets to sweep entire job site during final clean-up. - Warranty (Installation): TopTier Roofing's 25-year installation warranty. - Warranty (Product): Owens Corning's 10-year standard product warranty (prorated warranty following the first 10 years). - Discount: TopTier Roofing's 10% off Spring 2025 discount included. - Skylights: Includes the purchase and replacement of 2 skylights (mentioned in homeowner context, not detailed in image breakdown but included in scope). - Plywood: First 5 sheets of plywood are free (mentioned in homeowner context, detailed in image breakdown). - Final Cost Calculation: Quote subtotal $16,780.93, Credit ($1,678.09), Credited subtotal $15,102.84, Total $15,102.84.