Is $4,500 to remove chimney stack and perform roof/gutter work a fair price?
Project Details
I initially had roofers in to clean my roof, sort some gutterwork, and remove damaged lead flashing on the chimney. Following an inspection, they found structural problems with the chimney stack above the roof. The quote for removing the chimney stack down to inside the roof level jumped from an initial £680 to £4.5k. I felt stuck with them as they had started work and the chimney was unstable. I am concerned about the quality of the work, as the chimney stack inside isn't capped off and the felt has been torn where a ventilation tile was added and left hanging. I've already paid a £2k deposit and they are expecting the rest today. I am unsure if I am being ripped off and what I can do now, given I signed their invoice. This work is being carried out in England, in the South East about an hour outside of North London.
Quote Details
This quote covers the removal of the chimney stack and associated roof and gutter work, with a 10-year guarantee on the works performed. The scope includes: - To remove all existing bricks down to roof level - To install breathable membrane 1 metre each way from chimney - To install new treated battens - To install new Redland 49 tiles - To remove moss both sides of roof - To add moss chemical agent to stop moss - To install new joiners to gutter front and back - To clear all waste from job site - To install vent tiles where needed - To reinstall satellite dish to roof using new brackets - Works will be guaranteed for ten years
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$4,500
Quote Date
August 20, 2025
Roof material
Tile
Tearoff included?
No
Warranty period
10 years
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Repair and repoint chimney stack with new leadwork and fascia vents
Comprehensive chimney and roof maintenance including: - Install new over fascia vents to top of fascia boards - Fully grind out and repoint chimney stack - Reflaunch chimney stack with new mortar - Install new code 3 and 4 leadwork to chimney stacks including aprons and gutter backs - Seal leadwork into brickwork
Comprehensively repair chimney leak
This quote provides a comprehensive repair for the chimney leak. - Renewal of flaunching - Repointing of brickwork - Installation of new pots and flue covers - Application of storm dry cream sealant - Replacement of any required bricks - Scaffolding is required for the work
Re-point and re-flanch two chimney stacks
Work performed on two chimney stacks. - Re-pointing - Re-flanching - Includes scaffolding at the front - Verbally agreed to mend lead flashing, but this was not in the written contract and was not completed. - Concerns raised about quality: loose mortar on the back chimney stack and broken mortar left in the gutter. - Reason given for not fixing flashing: requires rear scaffolding.