Is $70,000 to replace the roof with metal or high-end shingles a fair price?
Project Details
The homeowner lives in upstate NY and has a 30-year-old roof. They were originally interested in metal but are now considering shingles due to cost. The salesperson used high-pressure sales tactics, including a 'right now' deal and insisting both spouses be present for the presentation.
Quote Details
Full roof replacement for a large 3000 sq ft roof. - Immediate 'right now' promotional pricing offered during initial presentation - Includes addressing questionable areas of the existing roof structure - High-pressure sales presentation approach
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$70,000
Quote Date
April 14, 2026
Location
New York
Home Size
3,000 sq ft
Roof size
3,000 sqft
Roof material
Metal
Tearoff included?
No
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace roof with metal shingles and replace fascia
Contract for roof and fascia replacement. - Scope: Replace roof and some fascia boards - Roof Area: Estimated 1800-2100 sq ft - Material: Metal asphalt roof, specifically described as "Cottage HD timber wood" metal shingles that are walkable - Note: Contract does not include an itemized list of costs
Install a metal roof
Full replacement of the roof with metal materials. - Accommodates a complex roof design - Metal roofing system
Tear off and replace roof with stone-coated steel or shingles
Full roof replacement for approximately 28-32 squares. - Complete tear off of existing roofing materials - Replacement of approximately 3 roof boards - Installation of new roofing system - Includes various 'discounts' from an initial $75,000 starting price