Is $20,000 to replace roof with Timberline shingles a fair price?
Project Details
I have entered a financing contract with this company, and after reading on here and other places, I've realized I am being vastly overcharged. I do have a notice to a right to recission in the contract and plan on utilizing it. I'm still in the grace period, but I'm concerned about how much pushback I should expect, especially since all the roofing company has done so far is sit in my dining room talking for 2 hours about the different GAF products they offered and an inspection. I just want an idea of how to do this beyond sending a notice to both the lender and this roofing company. For reference, I have another quote for $6k for something somewhat similar, and the sales guy from this company said I was probably getting cheaped out. I know I'm an idiot, but I caved to the high-pressure sales tactics this guy was utilizing (saying this shingle was a promo discount but could not guarantee it, so I had to make a decision today). I definitely plan on getting the cancellation through the rescind notice provided in the contract. The pushback is what I am most nervous about for sure, due to my state not having any extra provisions or protections on this type of thing.
Quote Details
This quote is for a roof replacement project, including the following items: - Inspection: Inspect wood sheathing - Flashing: Reflash all necessary and accessible areas - Shingle Installation: Install Timberline Shingles - Shingle Color: Charcoal - Underlayment: Install Weather Watch Ice and Water Shield on all eaves and in all valleys - Starter Shingles: Install Pro-Start Starter Shingles on all eaves and rakes - Ventilation: Install Cobra Snow Country Ridge Vent - Hip & Ridge Caps: Install Timbertex Seal-A-Ridge Hip & Ridge Caps - Hip & Ridge Cap Color: Matching Charcoal - Drip Edge Installation: Install Drip Edge on all Eaves/Rakes - Drip Edge Color: White - Cleanup: Remove all roofing debris and magnet sweep yard - Product Warranty: Lifetime (50 years)
You say...
Vote Distribution
These ratings are not endorsed by Quote Critic. They are submitted by other Quote Critic users like you.
More Details
Category
Roofing
Price
$20,000
Quote Date
June 17, 2025
Location
South Carolina
Roof material
Asphalt shingles
Tearoff included?
No
Warranty period
Lifetime (50 years)
Comments
No comments yet
Sign in to share your thoughts and ask questions.
Similar Quotes
Replace 2,300 sqft of roofing with a GAF Fortitude system
This quote is for the replacement of the existing roofing system on a 2,300 sqft roof, including both asphalt shingles and low-slope areas. This is described as a "high end package" and is expected to take one day. GAF - Fortitude Inclusions: - Installation of asphalt shingles - Drip edge - Ice and watershield - Synthetic roof deck protection - Starter strip - Premium ridge cap shingles - Power Ventilation System (intake ventilation, ridge vent exhaust, bath and kitchen exhaust) - Necessary flashings where applicable - Removal of existing shingles - Clean up and haul away of all job-related debris Low-slope roofing system includes: - Installation of self-adhered base and cap sheets - Drip edge - Necessary flashing, where applicable - Removal of existing roofing material - New decking - Clean up and haul away of all job-related debris Additional Costs: - Any wood that must be replaced will be done at a cost to the homeowner of $4.34 per square foot.
Replace roof with metal shingles and replace fascia
Contract for roof and fascia replacement. - Scope: Replace roof and some fascia boards - Roof Area: Estimated 1800-2100 sq ft - Material: Metal asphalt roof, specifically described as "Cottage HD timber wood" metal shingles that are walkable - Note: Contract does not include an itemized list of costs
Replace a 20 square roof with fixtures, flashing, and gutters
This quote is for a 20 square roof replacement at a fixed price, with additional costs for rot replacement. - Roof Size: 20 squares (2,000 sq ft) - Fixtures: 2 skylights - Additional Components: Flashing, Gutters - Rot Replacement: Approximately $750 per square (additional cost) - Promised Warranty: 50 years (GAF Golden Pledge) - Contracted Warranty: 10 years